Rentler home
  • Blog
  • About us
  • Blog
  • About us
$
$
  1. Home
  2. Search Rentals
  3. IN Properties for Rent
  4. Michigan City, IN Properties for Rent
  5. Rentals in Michigan City, IN under $1,500/mo

Rentals in Michigan City, IN under $1,500/mo 22 results

$1,300

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,000 sqft • House

3574 W US 20, La Porte, IN, 46350

La Porte House: 3574 W US 20

$1,400

3 beds • 1 bath • 884 sqft • House

931 Henry Street, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry StreetMichigan City House: 931 Henry Street
3 Bedroom

$1,105

2 beds • 2 baths • 864 sqft • Condo

335 Cedargate Court 335, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 335 Cedargate Court

$1,275

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,342 sqft • House

731 West 4th StUpper, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpperMichigan City House: 731 West 4th StUpper

$830

1 bed • 1 bath • 576 sqft • Condo

223 Cedargate Court 223, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate CourtMichigan City Condo: 223 Cedargate Court

$1,095

2 beds • 1 bath • House

1216 Kentucky St Apt A, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky StMichigan City House: 1216 Kentucky St

$1,050

2 beds • 1 bath • 778 sqft • House

409 Vail Street, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail StreetMichigan City House: 409 Vail Street

$1,149

2 beds • 2 baths • 1,015 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$1,027

2 beds • 1 bath • 1,000 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$837

1 bed • 1 bath • 685 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$904

1 bed • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$1,065

2 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,225 sqft • Apartment

5054 N. Pawnee Trail, La Porte, IN, 46350

La Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee TrailLa Porte Apartment: 5054 N. Pawnee Trail

$1,000

2 beds • 1 bath • House

1309 Franklin St., Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1309 Franklin St.

$1,105

2 beds • 2 baths • 864 sqft • Apartment

110 Cedar Gate Ct, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate Ct

$937

1 bed • 1 bath • 790 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$937

1 bed • 1 bath • 790 sqft • Apartment

221 Barker Rd #110, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker RdMichigan City Apartment: 221 Barker Rd

$997

2 beds • 1 bath • House

1313 Franklin St., Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.Michigan City House: 1313 Franklin St.

$1,325

2 beds • 2 baths • 964 sqft • Apartment

1000 Longbeach Ln, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach Ln

$975

2 beds • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Multiplex

1201 Manhattan St, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan StMichigan City Multiplex: 1201 Manhattan St

$830

1 bed • 1 bath • 576 sqft • Apartment

110 Cedar Gate Ct, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate CtMichigan City Apartment: 110 Cedar Gate Ct

$1,155

1 bed • 1 bath • 767 sqft • Apartment

1000 Longbeach Ln, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach LnMichigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach Ln

$1,425

2 beds • 2 baths • 1,188 sqft • Apartment

1000 Longbeach Ln, Michigan City, IN, 46360

Michigan City Apartment: 1000 Longbeach Ln

Showing 22 of 22 results

You have reached the end

Want to get notified about new listings?

What to Know Before Renting Under $1,500 in Michigan City, IN

Rentals under $1,500 per month cover a wide share of Michigan City inventory — expect a mix of one- and two-bedroom apartments, townhomes, and some three-bedroom houses. At this price point, tradeoffs are usually about neighborhood, building age, and amenity package rather than basic habitability. Compare commute time, parking, and in-unit laundry when narrowing your shortlist in Michigan City.

Browse Michigan City Rentals by Bedroom Count

Studio apartments for rent in Michigan City1-bedroom apartments for rent in Michigan City2-bedroom apartments for rent in Michigan City3-bedroom apartments for rent in Michigan City

Rentals Under $1,500 Near Michigan City, IN

Rentals Under $1,500 in Westville, INRentals Under $1,500 in Chesterton, INRentals Under $1,500 in Burns Harbor, INRentals Under $1,500 in La Porte, INRentals Under $1,500 in Valparaiso, INRentals Under $1,500 in Portage, IN

Frequently Asked Questions About Rentals Under $1,500 in Michigan City, IN

Rentler currently shows 20 rentals in Michigan City priced under $1,500. Inventory at this price point is updated daily — availability changes quickly, especially at the lower price tiers where well-priced units receive applications within 24–48 hours of posting.

At the under $1,500 price point in Michigan City, use the bedroom and property-type filters to narrow to studios, 1-bedrooms, 2-bedrooms, houses, or townhomes. Availability shifts daily — set a listing alert if you want to catch new units as they post.

These terms refer to different things. Cheap or affordable apartments are market-rate units at the lower end of a city's price range — anyone can apply regardless of income. Low-income or income-restricted apartments are subsidized properties (through programs like Section 8, HUD, or LIHTC) that require income qualification, typically at or below 50–80% of the area median income. Both types may appear on Rentler — contact landlords directly on lower-priced listings to ask about income requirements and subsidy acceptance.

Pet-friendly rentals exist across all price tiers. Use Rentler's pet-friendly filter to narrow to properties that accept animals. At lower price points, pet deposits and monthly pet rent still apply — factor that into your total monthly cost when budgeting. Breed and weight restrictions are common even on pet-accepting listings.

Yes — especially on market-rate listings with individual landlords, which make up a significant share of Rentler's inventory. Negotiating leverage is highest in winter (November through January), when fewer people are searching and landlords are more motivated to fill vacancies. Offering a longer lease term, a larger security deposit, or the ability to move in quickly are the most effective negotiating levers.

Other Resources for Michigan City, IN Renters

How to Rent an Apartment

How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide

Read more: How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide
what do apartments look for in background checks

What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?

Read more: What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?
locked out of apartment

Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do

Read more: Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do
how to find private landlords

How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter

Read more: How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter
how to write apartment address

How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples

Read more: How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples
cheapest states to live in

10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now

Read more: 10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now
what is a guarantor for an apartment

What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide

Read more: What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide
states with the lowest rent

States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less

Read more: States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less
cosigner for apartment

Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know

Read more: Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know
tandem parking

What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage

Read more: What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage
do apartments come furnished

Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter

Read more: Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter
how long does an application for an apartment take

How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?

Read more: How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?
Company
About RentlerList your place
Support
Help centerContact support
Resources
Tenant blogLandlord blogSite map
Rentler app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Terms of servicePrivacy policy
Secured
Equal Housing Opportunity
©2026 Rentler. All rights reserved.
Created in sunny Utah