$3,950
2 beds • 2 baths • 1,206 sqft • Apartment
4180 Sunrise Highway, Oakdale, NY, 11769
Showing 3 of 3 results
You have reached the end
Want to get notified about new listings?
Browse upscale rentals in Oakdale, NY. Find newer construction, premium finishes, and top amenities - updated daily on Rentler.
Luxury rentals in Oakdale typically feature upgraded finishes, modern appliances, and amenity-rich buildings — but "luxury" is not standardized, so tour units and read lease details carefully. Look for in-unit laundry, secure entry, fitness centers, and consistent maintenance response times. In Oakdale, luxury inventory is smaller than mid-market stock but often offers more space per dollar than central urban cores nearby.
Central Oakdale’s housing options feature primarily single-family homes and smaller rentals along the Montauk Highway corridor. 2-bedroom and 3-bedroom properties are common, with older and mid-era construction giving the community a classic South Shore feel. Prices are typical of Oakdale’s average of $3,227/mo, although luxury homes may command more. Pet-friendly homes with yards can be attractive to area renters, too. Montauk Highway provides easy access to shopping and dining, with nearby rail serving commuters. Those seeking a suburban setting with everyday conveniences close to home may appreciate what they find here in Central Oakdale.
Historic single-family homes, tree-lined streets, and quaint waterfront pockets distinguish Idle Hour from more conventional suburban Oakdale areas. Rental inventory is primarily larger homes with 3-bedroom or larger layouts, including some luxury properties near canals and the Connetquot River. Prices are usually above the Oakdale average of $3,227/mo, especially those with water access or scenic views. Local roads lead renters to Montauk Highway and nearby parks and outdoor spaces. Overall, Idle Hour appeals to renters who want architectural character, a quieter pace, and a coastal setting.
West Oakdale’s Vanderbilt area features spacious rental properties and tree-lined streets rather than apartment density. Here, renters will find single-family homes, sometimes on larger lots, typically with 3-bedroom or larger floor plans. Rents are typically higher than the local average of $3,227/mo, particularly for renovated or luxury properties. Pet-friendly rentals are also common here, with some having large yards. Connetquot River State Park Preserve is a major local attraction, with walking and outdoor recreation just minutes from home. Nature-minded renters will appreciate this quieter residential area.
East Oakdale features established residential streets, with smaller rental properties and single-family homes near the Sayville border. Most available properties feature 2-bedroom or 3-bedroom floor plans across mid-century construction. Monthly rental rates typically hover around Oakdale's average of $3,227/mo, with high-end luxury developments being limited. Depending on the property, select pet-friendly residences include private yards. Montauk Highway simplifies local retail trips, whereas Sunrise Highway streamlines regional commutes across Long Island. For households and couples who prioritize quiet suburban streets over coastal premium pricing, East Oakdale offers an ideal location.
Closer to the bay, South Oakdale includes single-family houses, cottages, and some seasonal rentals in a coastal setting. 2-bedroom and 3-bedroom layouts are typical, with rents ranging from the local average of $3,227/mo to above average for canal or bay proximity. Pet-friendly properties may suit renters who enjoy outdoor activities, although seasonal lease terms and pet rules should be checked carefully. Boating facilities, coastal recreational hubs, and surrounding seaside promenades define the neighborhood charm. Living in South Oakdale suits residents who want maritime activities with a laid-back suburban setting.
Rentler currently shows 3 luxury listings in Oakdale. Inventory is updated daily — use the filters above to refine by bedrooms, price, and property type.
Policies and inclusions vary by landlord. Read each listing carefully, confirm fees and restrictions in writing, and ask about move-in timing before paying an application fee. Having ID, proof of income, and references ready helps you move quickly when the right unit posts in Oakdale.
Many luxury listings also accept pets, but it is not automatic. Combine the pet-friendly filter with this page's filters, then confirm breed, weight, deposit, and pet-rent rules with each landlord.











