Rentler home
  • List your property
  • Blog
  • List your property
  • Blog
$
$
  1. Home
  2. Search Rentals
  3. NY Properties for Rent
  4. West Islip, NY Properties for Rent

9 Apartments, Houses, & Townhomes for Rent in West Islip, NY

9 Results

West Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st Street

$2,250

1 bed • 1 bath • 750 sqft • House

202 west 1st Street Center, West Islip, NY, 11795

West Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rdWest Islio Townhome: 878 Udall rd

$4,000

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,100 sqft • Townhome

878 Udall rd, West Islio, NY, 11795

West Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st Street

$1,750

1 bed • 1 bath • 330 sqft • House

202 west 1st Street, West Islip, NY, 11795

West Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st StreetWest Islip House: 202 west 1st Street

$1,200

Studio • 1 bath • 250 sqft • House

202 west 1st Street Right, West Islip, NY, 11795

west islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st stwest islip Other: 202 west 1st st

$1,550

1 bed • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Other

202 west 1st st, west islip, NY, 11795

West Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVE

$1,800

1 bed • 1 bath • Condo

39 ALTMAR AVE, West Islip, NY, 11795

West Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVEWest Islip Condo: 39 ALTMAR AVE

$1,800

1 bed • 1 bath • Condo

39 ALTMAR AVE, West Islip, NY, 11795

No photo available

$3,400

2 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,129 sqft • Apartment

1384 No. Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

No photo available

$3,400

2 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,153 sqft • Apartment

1384 No. Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY, 11706

Showing 9 of 9 results

You have reached the end

Want to get notified about new listings?

Browse West Islip Rentals by Bedroom Count

Studio apartments for rent in West Islip1-bedroom apartments for rent in West Islip2-bedroom apartments for rent in West Islip3-bedroom apartments for rent in West Islip

Rentals Near West Islip, NY

Rentals in Bay Shore, NYRentals in Central Islip, NYRentals in Commack, NYRentals in Oakdale, NYRentals in Patchogue, NY

Zips nearby West Islip, NY

11729117101170611704117511175711726117221175211701

Apartments nearby West Islip, NY

Bay Shore Apartments For RentCentral Islip Apartments For RentCommack Apartments For RentOakdale Apartments For RentPatchogue Apartments For Rent

Houses nearby West Islip, NY

Bay Shore Houses For RentCentral Islip Houses For Rent

Frequently Asked Questions About Renting in West Islip, NY

The fastest way to find affordable rentals in West Islip is to use Rentler's price filters — browse apartments under $800, under $1,000, or under $1,500 to see current inventory at each threshold. Availability at the lower price tiers changes quickly, so checking back regularly or setting a listing alert is worth doing. Older buildings and units further from city center tend to offer the most room on price.

Yes — West Islip has pet-friendly rentals listed on Rentler across apartments, houses, and townhomes. Use the pet-friendly filter to see only properties that accept animals. Policies vary by landlord — breed restrictions, weight limits, and whether a pet deposit or monthly pet rent applies are all worth confirming directly before submitting an application. Large-dog-friendly inventory tends to be stronger in suburban and townhome-style properties than in dense apartment buildings.

Rentler doesn't have a dedicated luxury filter, but you can surface higher-end rentals in West Islip by sorting listings by highest price and combining the recent-build and furnished filters. Newer construction properties typically offer the most upscale finishes available — in-unit laundry, stainless appliances, quartz countertops, and on-site amenities like a fitness center or pool.

Rentler focuses on traditional lease rentals rather than short-term or vacation stays. For stays under 3 months, platforms like Furnished Finder or Airbnb may have more options. For 3–6 month furnished leases in West Islip, use Rentler's furnished filter, which occasionally includes properties with flexible lease terms. Contact landlords directly to ask about lease length flexibility before applying.

Some landlords on Rentler offer move-in incentives like first month free, reduced security deposits, or waived application fees — especially during slower leasing seasons (October through February). These aren't filterable on Rentler directly. The best approach is to contact landlords on listings you're interested in and ask about current promotions before submitting an application.

Most landlords in West Islip require a government-issued photo ID, proof of income (typically 2.5–3x the monthly rent in gross income), recent pay stubs or bank statements, and consent for a background and credit check. Rentler applications are saved to your account so you can submit to multiple properties without re-entering your information each time. Having all documents ready before you find a unit puts you ahead of applicants who need extra time to gather materials.

State law provides several baseline protections for all renters: security deposits must typically be returned within a set window after move-out with an itemized deduction statement; landlords must give advance notice before entering a unit except in emergencies; and all rentals must meet basic habitability standards. For city-specific tenant protections, check with your local municipality — some cities have additional renter ordinances beyond state law.

Other Resources for West Islip, NY Renters

How to Rent an Apartment

How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide

Read more: How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide
what do apartments look for in background checks

What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?

Read more: What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?
locked out of apartment

Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do

Read more: Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do
how to find private landlords

How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter

Read more: How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter
how to write apartment address

How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples

Read more: How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples
cheapest states to live in

10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now

Read more: 10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now
what is a guarantor for an apartment

What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide

Read more: What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide
states with the lowest rent

States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less

Read more: States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less
cosigner for apartment

Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know

Read more: Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know
tandem parking

What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage

Read more: What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage
do apartments come furnished

Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter

Read more: Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter
how long does an application for an apartment take

How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?

Read more: How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?
About RentlerList your place
Help centerContact support
Tenant blogLandlord blogSitemap
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Terms of servicePrivacy policy
©2026 Rentler. All rights reserved.
Secured
Equal Housing Opportunity
Created in sunny Utah