Rentler home
  • Blog
  • About us
  • Blog
  • About us
$
$
  1. Home
  2. Search Rentals
  3. NY Properties for Rent
  4. Ithaca, NY Properties for Rent
  5. Luxury rentals in Ithaca, NY

Luxury rentals in Ithaca, NY 69 results

Show previous listings

$4,200

2 beds • 2 baths • Apartment

201 Oak Avenue, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak Avenue

$5,500

3 beds • 3 baths • Apartment

201 Oak Avenue, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak AvenueIthaca Apartment: 201 Oak Avenue

$4,095

2 beds • 1 bath • 715 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$5,445

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,035 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$4,045

2 beds • 1 bath • 715 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$4,895

2 beds • 1 bath • 1,000 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$4,895

2 beds • 1 bath • 1,000 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$4,095

2 beds • 1 bath • 715 sqft • Apartment

409 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College AveIthaca Apartment: 409 College Ave

$3,371+

2 beds • 2 baths • 849 sqft • Apartment

430 West State Street, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State Street

$4,100

2 beds • 1 bath • 638 sqft • Apartment

325 College Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College AveIthaca Apartment: 325 College Ave

$3,554+

2 beds • 2 baths • 993 sqft • Apartment

430 West State Street, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State StreetIthaca Apartment: 430 West State Street

$4,500

5 beds • 2 baths • Apartment

311 Farm St, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm StIthaca Apartment: 311 Farm St

$4,040

5 beds • 2 baths • 1,466 sqft • Apartment

516 University Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University AveIthaca Apartment: 516 University Ave

$5,125

5 beds • 2 baths • Apartment

110-113 Stewart Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 110-113 Stewart Ave

$4,400

5 beds • 2 baths • 1,600 sqft • Apartment

516 University Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 516 University Ave

$10,125

9 beds • 3 baths • Apartment

522 Stewart Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart Ave

$9,675

9 beds • 4 baths • Apartment

522 Stewart Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart Ave

$6,100

5 beds • 2 baths • Apartment

522 Stewart Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart Ave

$5,000

5 beds • 2 baths • 1,350 sqft • Apartment

200 Highland Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland AveIthaca Apartment: 200 Highland Ave

$5,875

5 beds • 2 baths • Apartment

522 Stewart Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart AveIthaca Apartment: 522 Stewart Ave

$10,800

8 beds • 3 baths • 3,000 sqft • Apartment

306 Bryant Ave, Ithaca, NY, 14850

Ithaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant AveIthaca Apartment: 306 Bryant Ave

Showing 21 of 69 results

You have reached the end

Want to get notified about new listings?

  • Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Luxury Rentals in Ithaca, NY

Browse upscale rentals in Ithaca, NY. Find newer construction, premium finishes, and top amenities - updated daily on Rentler.

What to Know Before Renting a Luxury Apartment in Ithaca, NY

Luxury rentals in Ithaca typically feature upgraded finishes, modern appliances, and amenity-rich buildings — but "luxury" is not standardized, so tour units and read lease details carefully. Look for in-unit laundry, secure entry, fitness centers, and consistent maintenance response times. In Ithaca, luxury inventory is smaller than mid-market stock but often offers more space per dollar than central urban cores nearby.

Luxury Rental Details by Ithaca Neighborhood

Collegetown

Living just steps from Cornell University is perhaps the biggest draw to renting in Collegetown, where student-oriented apartments, divided homes, and smaller multifamily buildings make up the rental market. Studio, 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, and some 3-bedroom floor plans are common, with some renovated and luxury properties dotted throughout the area. Rent prices are typical of the Ithaca average of $2,313/mo. College Avenue is home to cafes, restaurants, and shopping, putting everyday conveniences close. Some pet-friendly rentals are also available. For students and university staff, Collegetown can be a great option.

Downtown Ithaca/The Commons

Downtown Ithaca residents enjoy exceptional walkability thanks to TCAT bus lines, local boutiques, and a lively dining scene. Multi-unit developments and converted historic properties offer a blend of studio, 1-bedroom, and 2-bedroom apartments or houses. Rental rates typically sit at or above the Ithaca average of $2,313/mo, while renovated units directly around The Commons command luxury pricing. Main corridors like State and Green Streets put central amenities close to home. While private yards are rare, commuters, local workers, and those searching for pet-friendly accommodations will value the urban convenience.

Fall Creek

Historic houses and tree-lined streets give Fall Creek a neighborhood feel within walking distance of downtown Ithaca. Single-family homes, duplexes, and smaller apartments offer 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, and 3-bedroom floor plans, often with quaint architectural details. Rent prices typically range from the area average of $2,313/mo and up, with renovated and luxury properties costing more. Local parks and the creek's natural surroundings add outdoor appeal, while some pet-friendly homes include yards. For Cornell University staff, couples, and households seeking residential charm, Fall Creek offers a quieter place to settle without leaving central Ithaca behind.

Belle Sherman/East Hill

Belle Sherman and East Hill offer a quieter home near Cornell University, with residential streets that provide an alternative to busy Collegetown. Older and mid-century single-family homes make up much of the rental inventory, alongside a smaller selection of apartments. Most rentals feature 2-bedroom or 3-bedroom layouts, with rents sitting at or above the local average of $2,313/mo, with occasional luxury properties asking more. East State Street and nearby routes connect residents with campus and downtown. Families, Cornell faculty, and professionals may appreciate the calmer setting, especially when a pet-friendly property includes a private yard.

South Hill

Natural scenery and diverse housing options attract renters seeking more space than central Ithaca. Rentals include student apartments, older houses, and updated single-family homes offering 1-bedroom, 2-bedroom, and 3-bedroom floor plans. Monthly rental rates sit near the Ithaca city average of $2,313/mo, with fewer luxury developments than neighboring areas. Key routes such as Danby Road and South Aurora Street provide convenient access to downtown and Ithaca College. For students, staff, and renters seeking pet-friendly units with private yards, the quiet location is a major draw.

Browse Ithaca Rentals by Bedroom Count

Studio apartments for rent in Ithaca1-bedroom apartments for rent in Ithaca2-bedroom apartments for rent in Ithaca3-bedroom apartments for rent in Ithaca

Luxury Rentals Near Ithaca, NY

Luxury Rentals in Cortland, NY

Frequently Asked Questions About Luxury Rentals in Ithaca, NY

Rentler currently shows 72 luxury listings in Ithaca. Inventory is updated daily — use the filters above to refine by bedrooms, price, and property type.

Policies and inclusions vary by landlord. Read each listing carefully, confirm fees and restrictions in writing, and ask about move-in timing before paying an application fee. Having ID, proof of income, and references ready helps you move quickly when the right unit posts in Ithaca.

Many luxury listings also accept pets, but it is not automatic. Combine the pet-friendly filter with this page's filters, then confirm breed, weight, deposit, and pet-rent rules with each landlord.

Other Resources for Ithaca, NY Renters

How to Rent an Apartment

How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide

Read more: How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide
what do apartments look for in background checks

What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?

Read more: What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?
locked out of apartment

Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do

Read more: Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do
how to find private landlords

How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter

Read more: How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter
how to write apartment address

How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples

Read more: How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples
cheapest states to live in

10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now

Read more: 10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now
what is a guarantor for an apartment

What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide

Read more: What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide
states with the lowest rent

States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less

Read more: States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less
cosigner for apartment

Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know

Read more: Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know
tandem parking

What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage

Read more: What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage
do apartments come furnished

Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter

Read more: Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter
how long does an application for an apartment take

How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?

Read more: How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?
Company
About RentlerList your place
Support
Help centerContact support
Resources
Tenant blogLandlord blogSite map
Rentler app
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Terms of servicePrivacy policy
Secured
Equal Housing Opportunity
©2026 Rentler. All rights reserved.
Created in sunny Utah