How many houses are available in Gary right now?

Rentler currently shows 30 houses for rent in Gary. Inventory updates daily — set a listing alert if you want to catch new units as they post.

What should I look for when renting houses in Gary?

Compare monthly rent against parking, laundry, storage, and commute. Confirm what is included in rent, who handles maintenance, and any HOA or community rules before you apply. In Gary, well-priced houses can move quickly once listed.

Can I find pet-friendly houses in Gary?

Yes — many houses accept pets, though policies vary. Use Rentler's pet-friendly filter, then confirm breed, weight, and deposit requirements with the landlord before submitting an application.

Houses for Rent in Gary, IN

32 Results

$1,400

3 beds1 bath1,300 sqftHouse

3395 Pennsylvania St, Gary, IN, 46409

New Paint

$1,700

3 beds2 baths1,344 sqftHouse

1954 McKinley St, Gary, IN, 46404

$750

1 bed1 bathHouse

1301 Pennsylvania St 5, Gary, IN, 46407

$1,750

3 beds1 bathHouse

2637 central drive, Gary, IN, 46407

$1,000

2 beds1 bathHouse

3808 Washington St, Gary, IN, 46408

$1,750

4 beds2 baths2,000 sqftHouse

3527 Mississippi St, Gary, IN, 46409

$1,750

3 beds1 bathHouse

907 Central Ave, Gary, IN, 46407

$1,400

2 beds1 bath750 sqftHouse

5129 E 10th Ave, Gary, IN, 46403

$1,325

3 beds1 bath1,051 sqftHouse

2425 Prospect St, Gary, IN, 46407

$1,250

2 beds1 bathHouse

1166 Mount St, Gary, IN, 46406

$1,750

4 beds2 bathsHouse

2025 W 4th Pl, Gary, IN, 46404

$1,465

2 beds1 bath787 sqftHouse

3102 West 40th Street, Hobart, IN, 46342

$1,250

2 beds1 bath1,001 sqftHouse

1361 Ellsworth St, Gary, IN, 46404

$1,100

2 beds1.5 bathsHouse

4200 Van Buren St, Gary, IN, 46408

$1,450

2 beds1 bath850 sqftHouse

4924 Adams Street, Gary, IN, 46408

$995

2 beds1 bath866 sqftHouse

2358 Vermont St, Gary, IN, 46407

$1,200

3 beds1 bathHouse

3927 Rhode Island St, Gary, IN, 46409

$1,200

2 beds1 bathHouse

5121 E 10th Ave, Gary, IN, 46403

$1,100

3 beds1 bath818 sqftHouse

3825 Connecticut, Gary, IN, 46409

$1,441

3 beds1.5 bathsHouse

308 Fillmore St, Gary, IN, 46402

$1,188

2 beds1 bathHouse

3449 Johnson St, Gary, IN, 46408

$1,075

2 beds1 bath850 sqftHouse

1325 E 7th Ave, Gary, IN, 46402

$1,200

3 beds1 bathHouse

210 Rutledge St., Gary, IN, 46404

$1,275

3 beds1.5 baths840 sqftHouse

4639 Connecticut St, Gary, IN, 46409

Showing 24 of 32 results

What to Know Before Renting a House in Gary, IN

Single-family houses for rent in Gary appeal to families and renters who want yards and garage parking. Houses lease less frequently than apartments, so set alerts and act quickly when a match appears. Confirm lawn care, utility splits, pet fences, and maintenance response expectations with the landlord before signing.