Rentler home
  • List your property
  • Blog
  • List your property
  • Blog
$
$
  1. Home
  2. Search Rentals
  3. IN Properties for Rent
  4. Gary, IN Properties for Rent
  5. Homes for Rent in Gary, IN

40 Homes for Rent in Gary, IN

40 Results

Gary House: 1751 Hayes St

$2,250

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,500 sqft • House

1751 Hayes St, Gary, IN, 46404

Gary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania StGary House: 2361 Pennsylvania St
Apply Now

$1,100

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,000 sqft • House

2361 Pennsylvania St, Gary, IN, 46407

Gary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King StGary House: 734 King St

$1,675

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,073 sqft • House

734 King St, Gary, IN, 46406

Gary House: 952 Hobart St

$1,950

4 beds • 2 baths • 1,873 sqft • House

952 Hobart St, Gary, IN, 46406

Gary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller AveGary House: 6520 Miller Ave

$1,500

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,247 sqft • House

6520 Miller Ave, Gary, IN, 46403

Gary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley StGary House: 1954 McKinley St
New Paint

$1,700

3 beds • 2 baths • 1,344 sqft • House

1954 McKinley St, Gary, IN, 46404

Gary House: 352 Matthews StGary House: 352 Matthews StGary House: 352 Matthews StGary House: 352 Matthews StGary House: 352 Matthews StGary House: 352 Matthews St

$1,200

2 beds • 1 bath • House

352 Matthews St, Gary, IN, 46406

Gary House: 763 Pierce StGary House: 763 Pierce StGary House: 763 Pierce StGary House: 763 Pierce St

$1,500

3 beds • 2 baths • House

763 Pierce St, Gary, IN, 46402

Gary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington StGary House: 3804 Washington St

$795

1 bed • 1 bath • House

3804 Washington St 3, Gary, IN, 46408

Gary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th Ave
Apply Now

$1,350

2 beds • 0.5 baths • 1,131 sqft • House

1676 W 13th Ave, Gary, IN, 46404

Gary House: 1676 W 13th AveGary House: 1676 W 13th Ave
Apply Now

$1,500

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,131 sqft • House

1676 W 13th Ave, Gary, IN, 46404

No photo available

$1,650

4 beds • 1 bath • 1,952 sqft • House

833 Fillmore St, Gary, IN, 46402

Gary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson StGary House: 2700 Jefferson St

$950

2 beds • 1 bath • 747 sqft • House

2700 Jefferson St, Gary, IN, 46407

Gary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur StreetGary House: 1047 Decatur Street

$1,550

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,150 sqft • House

1047 Decatur Street, Gary, IN, 46403

Gary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th PlGary House: 2025 W 4th Pl

$1,750

4 beds • 2 baths • House

2025 W 4th Pl, Gary, IN, 46404

Gary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore StGary House: 833 Fillmore St

$1,650

4 beds • 1.5 baths • 1,650 sqft • House

833 Fillmore St, Gary, IN, 46402

Hobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow StreetHobart House: 4020 Willow Street

$1,750

3 beds • 1 bath • 864 sqft • House

4020 Willow Street, Hobart, IN, 46342

Gary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley StGary House: 573 Hanley St

$1,590

3 beds • 1 bath • 1,000 sqft • House

573 Hanley St, Gary, IN, 46406

Gary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th PlGary House: 1272 E 36th Pl

$1,850

5 beds • 2 baths • 2,676 sqft • House

1272 E 36th Pl, Gary, IN, 46409

Gary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th AveGary House: 2551 W 12th Ave

$1,200

4 beds • 2 baths • House

2551 W 12th Ave, Gary, IN, 46404

Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.Gary House: 1327 W 41st Ave.

$1,200

2 beds • 1 bath • House

1327 W 41st Ave., Gary, IN, 46408

Gary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th AveGary House: 3813 E 13th Ave

$1,500

3 beds • 1 bath • House

3813 E 13th Ave, Gary, IN, 46403

Gary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 VermontGary House: 4317 Vermont

$1,500

3 beds • 1.5 baths • House

4317 Vermont, Gary, IN, 46409

Gary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft StGary House: 535 Taft St

$1,500

3 beds • 1.5 baths • House

535 Taft St, Gary, IN, 46404

Showing 24 of 40 results

Showing 24 of 40 results

Load more
  • 1
  • 2
  • Next

What to Know Before Renting a House in Gary, IN

Single-family houses for rent in Gary appeal to families and renters who want yards and garage parking. Houses lease less frequently than apartments, so set alerts and act quickly when a match appears. Confirm lawn care, utility splits, pet fences, and maintenance response expectations with the landlord before signing.

Browse Gary Rentals by Bedroom Count

Studio apartments for rent in Gary1-bedroom apartments for rent in Gary2-bedroom apartments for rent in Gary3-bedroom apartments for rent in Gary

Other Areas with Available Houses Near Gary, IN

Houses in Hobart, INHouses in Griffith, INHouses in Merrillville, INHouses in Highland, INHouses in East Chicago, INHouses in Hammond, INHouses in Portage, INHouses in Schererville, INHouses in Lansing, ILHouses in Whiting, IN

Frequently Asked Questions About Houses in Gary, IN

Rentler currently shows 37 houses for rent in Gary. Inventory updates daily — set a listing alert if you want to catch new units as they post.

Compare monthly rent against parking, laundry, storage, and commute. Confirm what is included in rent, who handles maintenance, and any HOA or community rules before you apply. In Gary, well-priced houses can move quickly once listed.

Yes — many houses accept pets, though policies vary. Use Rentler's pet-friendly filter, then confirm breed, weight, and deposit requirements with the landlord before submitting an application.

Other Resources for Gary, IN Renters

How to Rent an Apartment

How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide

Read more: How to Rent an Apartment: Total Step-by-Step Guide
what do apartments look for in background checks

What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?

Read more: What Do Apartments Look For in Background Checks?
locked out of apartment

Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do

Read more: Locked Out of Your Apartment? Here’s What to Do
how to find private landlords

How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter

Read more: How to Find Private Landlords as a Renter
how to write apartment address

How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples

Read more: How to Write an Apartment Address: USPS Format and Examples
cheapest states to live in

10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now

Read more: 10 Cheapest States to Live In Right Now
what is a guarantor for an apartment

What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide

Read more: What Is a Guarantor for an Apartment? A Renter’s Guide
states with the lowest rent

States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less

Read more: States with the Lowest Rent: Where to Rent for Less
cosigner for apartment

Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know

Read more: Getting a Cosigner for an Apartment: Everything Renters Need to Know
tandem parking

What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage

Read more: What Is Tandem Parking? A Renter’s Guide to Car Storage
do apartments come furnished

Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter

Read more: Do Apartments Come Furnished? What to Know as a Renter
how long does an application for an apartment take

How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?

Read more: How Long Does an Application for an Apartment Take?
About RentlerList your place
Help centerContact support
Tenant blogLandlord blogSitemap
Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Terms of servicePrivacy policy
©2026 Rentler. All rights reserved.
Secured
Equal Housing Opportunity
Created in sunny Utah