$1,339
2 beds • 1 bath • 800 sqft • Apartment
838 N Elmer St #4, Griffith, IN, 46319
$1,339
2 beds • 1 bath • 800 sqft • Apartment
838 N Elmer St #4, Griffith, IN, 46319
$910
2 beds • 1 bath • 500 sqft • Apartment
2301 Waverly Dr, Gary, IN, 46404
$990
2 beds • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Apartment
2301 Waverly Dr, Gary, IN, 46404
$1,300
3 beds • 1 bath • House
549 E 47th Pl, Gary, IN, 46409
$850
2 beds • 1 bath • 830 sqft • Apartment
405 S. Huntington St, Gary, IN, 46403
$1,200
3 beds • 1 bath • House
2700 Central Dr, Gary, IN, 46407
$1,331
3 beds • 1 bath • House
1088 Stevenson St, Gary, IN, 46406
$1,300
2 beds • 1 bath • Multiplex
2041 - 2043 Union St., Lake Station, IN, 46405
$1,300
2 beds • 1 bath • Apartment
200-238 E 45th Ave., Gary, IN, 46409
$1,300
2 beds • 1 bath • Apartment
1340 Washington St. Unit 102, Gary, IN, 46407
$750
6 beds • 3 baths • 1,080 sqft • House
387 S Hamilton St, Gary, IN, 46403
$1,299
3 beds • 1 bath • 939 sqft • House
3929 13th Ave, Gary, IN, 46403
$1,075
2 beds • 1 bath • 900 sqft • House
2358 Vermont St, Gary, IN, 46407
$885
2 beds • 1 bath • Apartment
1514 W 5th Ave, Gary, IN, 46402
$1,383
2 beds • 1 bath • 1,030 sqft • Apartment
838 N Elmer St #4, Griffith, IN, 46319
$1,339
2 beds • 1 bath • 800 sqft • Apartment
838 N Elmer St #4, Griffith, IN, 46319
$1,300
2 beds • 1 bath • Multiplex
1176 Fillmore Street - Unit 2, Gary, IN, 46407
$1,300
3 beds • 1 bath • 1,100 sqft • Multiplex
1176 Fillmore Street - Unit 1, Gary, IN, 46407
$1,300
2 beds • 1 bath • 830 sqft • House
4537 Park Avenue, Lake Station, IN, 46405
$885
2 beds • 1 bath • Apartment
1514 W 5th Ave, Gary, IN, 46402
$850
2 beds • 1 bath • Apartment
1126 Rutledge St., Gary, IN, 46404
$1,079
2 beds • 1 bath • Multiplex
1810-12 Virginia St, Gary, IN, 46407
$990
2 beds • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Apartment
2301 Waverly Dr, Gary, IN, 46404
$990
2 beds • 1 bath • 750 sqft • Apartment
2301 Waverly Dr, Gary, IN, 46404
Showing 24 of 58 results
Showing 24 of 58 results
Load moreRentals under $1,500 per month cover a wide share of Gary inventory — expect a mix of one- and two-bedroom apartments, townhomes, and some three-bedroom houses. At this price point, tradeoffs are usually about neighborhood, building age, and amenity package rather than basic habitability. Compare commute time, parking, and in-unit laundry when narrowing your shortlist in Gary.
Rentler currently shows 46 rentals in Gary priced under $1,500. Inventory at this price point is updated daily — availability changes quickly, especially at the lower price tiers where well-priced units receive applications within 24–48 hours of posting.
At the under $1,500 price point in Gary, use the bedroom and property-type filters to narrow to studios, 1-bedrooms, 2-bedrooms, houses, or townhomes. Availability shifts daily — set a listing alert if you want to catch new units as they post.
These terms refer to different things. Cheap or affordable apartments are market-rate units at the lower end of a city's price range — anyone can apply regardless of income. Low-income or income-restricted apartments are subsidized properties (through programs like Section 8, HUD, or LIHTC) that require income qualification, typically at or below 50–80% of the area median income. Both types may appear on Rentler — contact landlords directly on lower-priced listings to ask about income requirements and subsidy acceptance.
Pet-friendly rentals exist across all price tiers. Use Rentler's pet-friendly filter to narrow to properties that accept animals. At lower price points, pet deposits and monthly pet rent still apply — factor that into your total monthly cost when budgeting. Breed and weight restrictions are common even on pet-accepting listings.
Yes — especially on market-rate listings with individual landlords, which make up a significant share of Rentler's inventory. Negotiating leverage is highest in winter (November through January), when fewer people are searching and landlords are more motivated to fill vacancies. Offering a longer lease term, a larger security deposit, or the ability to move in quickly are the most effective negotiating levers.











